We are totally stumped by this one. Blogger Gentleman Agitator emailed to tell BrandlandUSA of his frustration with a new Holiday Inn logo.
Don’t get us wrong. We love Holiday Inn. But we loved their old lettering.OK, so we here at BrandlandUSA were hopeful that it was the other way around. Perhaps Holiday Inn was bringing back the GREAT SIGN of the Kemmons Wilson era? But no. The new logo is pictured at right, and it was designed by the firm Interbrand for Holiday Inn, a unit of Intercontinental Hotels, NYSE ticker IHG. It comes at a time when the stock has come down from a $25 high in 2007 to around $13 in this latest bear market.
According to an IHG press release, 11 Holiday Inn and Holiday Inn Express hotels across Europe, Middle East and Africa – plus 19 in the United States and six across Asia Pacific – have been chosen to road-test the changes to the world’s biggest hotel brand, which includes new bedding, new shower experience and, for the first time, a signature scent and sound package. The first two to open in Europe, both in the UK, are the Holiday Inn London Heathrow and the Holiday Inn Farnborough.
In the redesign, they have redone the logo, and eliminated all traces of the old 1950s script. One thing that remains is the green color. The scent is new. Wonder what the scent is all about?
Here is BrandlandUSA’s fear. The new hotels will be significantly improved. And customers will like them. But the problem with that logic is that because so many other things have been improved about the hotels, consumers will feel positive about the changes, even as it has nothing to do with the actual look and feel of the logo. It would be as if you did a pharmaceutical test, and had a control group that not only took the new pills, but also exercised and had a low fat diet at the same time. It seems like IHG, then, already has the answer it wants.
We understand the need for a bit of freshening up. It does a brand some good. No less than our favorite thinker on brands and type, the late Professor Philip Meggs of Richmond’s Virginia Commonwealth University, said that very often, a company could get great mileage out of a logo change. It was a cheap way to change the message.
But we wonder what Prof. Meggs would say about this change, which is rather like changing the script on the Coca-Cola logo or the Campbell’s Soup Can. The Holiday Inn lettering is classic. They could even name a font after it.
And we wonder, then, if Holiday Inn dumps all versions of the old script, can they rightfully keep other hotels from using the old Holiday Inn script for their new signs when they aren’t protecting it by using it?
It’s not a bad logo, as logos go. But we miss the old one. We hope this move works, and helps Holiday Inn. It’s one of our fave hotel chains. We love Holidome. We love Holidex. We love Sun Spree. We loved those great kids meals with the pirate hats! But our fear is that sometimes, these sorts of typographic changes only are surface dressing. And other more important changes, like more rigorous inspection of hotels, would get forgotten in the clamor to put up new signs and root out stationary that doesn’t conform to the new brand image.
There is one good thing. The AWFUL plastic signs that replaced the GREAT SIGN of Kemmons Wilson will finally disappear. Read Andrew Nelson’s seminal article on the Great Sign, which appeared in the online magazine Salon. He called the replacement signs “backlit, crapola plastic.” And he was right.
We hope that Holiday Inn can do something sensible. First, we hope that all the old lettering won’t have to disappear from every scrap of paper, trash can and such. That is an expensive process for franchisees. Us Priority Club members LOVE the old script. Furthermore, if some versions of the brand continue to stay, it gives the company a bit of history. After all, the previous images of the brand name will continue to exist in the media forever.
Ideas? Comments? Leave a comment after this story. We love to hear about old brands being revived, dead brands resuscitated or great brands in jeopardy. We will help spread the word. Click Here To Send E-mail